Skip to Content

10 Tasty Buffalo Chicken Sandwich Toppings

Buffalo chicken sandwiches are one of my favorite go-to meals.

They’re easy to make, delicious, and filling.

But let’s be honest: sometimes they can get a little boring.

That’s why I love experimenting with different toppings on my buffalo chicken sandwiches.

From creamy avocado to crunchy slaw, there are so many tasty options that will take your sandwich from ordinary to extraordinary!

In this article, I’m going to share 10 of the best topping ideas for your next buffalo chicken sandwich – you won’t believe how good they taste!

Read Also: Buffalo Chicken Wine Pairing – The Best Wines for Buffalo Chicken

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

10 Tasty Buffalo Chicken Sandwich Toppings

Buffalo chicken sandwiches are a great meal to enjoy, but they can be even better with the right topping.

Here are ten tasty additions that will take your buffalo chicken sandwich to the next level:

1. Avocado

Avocado
  • Taste: Avocado has a mild, buttery flavor that pairs well with the spicy kick of buffalo chicken. It adds a creamy richness to the sandwich without overpowering it.
  • Texture: The texture of avocado is smooth and creamy, making it an ideal topping for sandwiches. It also helps to balance out the crunchiness of fried chicken or other toppings like lettuce and tomato.
  • Variations: Avocado can be used in many different ways on buffalo chicken sandwiches. Try adding slices of fresh avocado or mashed avocado spread onto the bun before adding your chicken and other toppings. You can also mix diced avocado into your favorite ranch dressing for a delicious twist on classic buffalo sauce!

2. Crispy bacon

Crispy Bacon
  • Taste: Bacon is a classic topping for buffalo chicken sandwiches because of its smoky, salty flavor. The bacon adds an extra layer of savory flavor to the sandwich that complements the spicy kick from the buffalo sauce.
  • Texture: Bacon also adds a nice crunchy texture to the sandwich. The crispy bacon contrasts nicely with the softness of the bread and chicken, making each bite more interesting and enjoyable.
  • Variations: There are many different types of bacon you can use on your buffalo chicken sandwich. You can try using thick-cut or thin-cut bacon, smoked or unsmoked, or even turkey bacon if you want something lighter. You can also experiment with different flavors such as maple-glazed or honey-cured for an added sweetness to balance out the spiciness of the buffalo sauce.

3. Pickled jalapenos

  • Taste: Pickled jalapenos are a great topping for buffalo chicken sandwiches because they add a tangy, spicy flavor that complements the heat of the buffalo sauce. The pickling process also helps to mellow out the spiciness of the jalapenos, making them more palatable for those who don’t like too much heat.
  • Texture: Pickled jalapenos have a crunchy texture that adds an interesting contrast to the softness of the sandwich bread and chicken. They also provide a nice pop of color and visual appeal to your dish.
  • Variations: If you want to switch up your pickled jalapeno topping, there are plenty of variations you can try. You can use different types of peppers such as serranos or habaneros for extra spice, or even bell peppers if you prefer something milder. You can also experiment with different vinegars and spices in your brine for unique flavors.

4. Red onion

red onion
  • Taste: Red onions have a mild, sweet flavor that is slightly spicy. They are not as pungent as white or yellow onions, but they still have a sharp bite when eaten raw. The sweetness of red onions becomes more pronounced when cooked and can be used to add depth of flavor to dishes.
  • Texture: Red onions are crisp and crunchy with thin layers of flesh that easily separate from each other. When cooked, the texture softens and the onion takes on a sweeter taste.
  • Variations: Red onions can be used in many different ways in cooking. They can be grilled, roasted, sautéed, pickled, or eaten raw in salads or sandwiches like buffalo chicken sandwiches. Pickling red onions adds an extra layer of flavor to dishes and gives them a bright pink hue that makes them stand out on the plate.

5. Blue cheese

Blue cheese
  • Taste: Blue cheese has a strong, salty flavor that is often described as pungent. It can range from mild to sharp depending on the variety and age of the cheese. The taste of blue cheese is often compared to that of Roquefort or Gorgonzola, two other types of blue-veined cheeses.
  • Texture: Blue cheese has a creamy texture with a crumbly consistency due to its veins of mold. The texture can vary depending on the type and age of the cheese, but it generally ranges from soft and spreadable to firm and crumbly.
  • Variations: There are many different varieties of blue cheese available, including Roquefort, Gorgonzola, Stilton, Maytag Blue Cheese, Danish Blue Cheese, Fourme d’Ambert and Bleu d’Auvergne. Each type has its own unique flavor profile and texture so it’s important to choose one that best suits your recipe or dish.

6. Sriracha mayo

  • Taste: Sriracha mayo is a creamy condiment that combines the spicy kick of sriracha with the smoothness of mayonnaise. The combination creates a unique flavor that is both tangy and spicy, making it perfect for adding an extra layer of flavor to sandwiches, burgers, and wraps.
  • Texture: Sriracha mayo has a thick texture that coats whatever it’s added to. It adds creaminess and richness to dishes without overpowering them.
  • Variations: There are many variations on sriracha mayo, such as adding garlic or lime juice for extra zest. You can also use different types of hot sauce in place of sriracha if you prefer a milder heat level. For those who don’t like spice at all, you can make a version with just mayonnaise and no hot sauce for a more subtle flavor profile.

7. Sliced tomatoes

Tomato Slices
  • Taste: Tomatoes are a classic topping for buffalo chicken sandwiches. The sweet, juicy flavor of the tomatoes pairs perfectly with the spicy buffalo sauce and creamy ranch dressing. The acidity of the tomatoes also helps to balance out the richness of the other ingredients.
  • Texture: Sliced tomatoes add a nice crunchy texture to a buffalo chicken sandwich. The contrast between the soft bread, creamy sauces, and tender chicken is enhanced by adding some crispness from the tomato slices.
  • Variations: If you want to switch up your buffalo chicken sandwich, try using different types of tomatoes such as cherry or grape tomatoes instead of slicing larger ones. You can also experiment with different flavors by adding herbs like basil or oregano to your tomato slices before putting them on your sandwich.

8. Creamy ranch dressing

  • Taste: Creamy ranch dressing is a classic condiment for buffalo chicken sandwiches. It has a tangy, creamy flavor that complements the spicy kick of the buffalo sauce. The combination of mayonnaise, buttermilk, and herbs gives it a unique flavor that pairs perfectly with the flavors of the sandwich.
  • Texture: Creamy ranch dressing has a thick, creamy texture that coats the sandwich and helps to cool down the heat from the buffalo sauce. The addition of buttermilk also adds an extra layer of creaminess to this condiment.
  • Variations: There are many variations on creamy ranch dressing that can be used as a topping for buffalo chicken sandwiches. For example, you can add diced celery or carrots for crunch or use Greek yogurt instead of mayonnaise for added protein and health benefits. You can also experiment with different herbs such as dill or parsley to give your dressing an extra boost in flavor.

9. Caramelized onions

  • Taste: Caramelized onions have a sweet, savory flavor that is enhanced by the slow cooking process. The natural sugars in the onions are released and caramelize as they cook, giving them a deep golden color and rich flavor.
  • Texture: When cooked properly, caramelized onions should be soft and tender with a slight crunch. They should not be mushy or overly crisp.
  • Variations: There are many variations of caramelized onions that can be used to top off your buffalo chicken sandwich. Try adding garlic or herbs for extra flavor, or use balsamic vinegar to add sweetness and acidity. You can also experiment with different types of onion such as red onion or shallots for a unique twist on this classic topping.

10. Cucumber slices

Cucumber slices
  • Taste: Cucumber slices add a refreshing crunch to the buffalo chicken sandwich. They have a mild, slightly sweet flavor that pairs well with the spicy buffalo sauce and creamy ranch dressing.
  • Texture: The cucumber slices provide a nice contrast in texture to the soft bread, juicy chicken, and creamy sauces. The crispness of the cucumbers helps to balance out all of the other flavors in the sandwich.
  • Variations: If you want to switch up your buffalo chicken sandwich, try adding different vegetables such as lettuce or tomato slices instead of cucumber slices. You can also experiment with different types of cheese or even grilled onions for an extra layer of flavor.

Conclusion

In conclusion, a delicious buffalo chicken sandwich can be taken to the next level with the right toppings.

From creamy ranch dressing to pickled jalapenos and everything in between, there are many tasty options to choose from.

The best buffalo chicken sandwich toppings are avocado, crispy bacon, pickled jalapenos, red onion, blue cheese, Sriracha mayo, sliced tomatoes, creamy ranch dressing, caramelized onions, and cucumber slices.

Each of these ingredients adds a unique flavor and texture to your sandwich, so you can mix and match to create the sandwich of your dreams.

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

10 Tasty Buffalo Chicken Sandwich Toppings

These days, I'm all about spicing up my sandwiches with something new and unexpected. That's why I'm sharing my top 10 favorite Buffalo Chicken Sandwich Toppings. From homemade blue cheese dressing to crunchy celery, these recipes will take your sandwich to the next level. Not only are they easy to make, but they'll add a unique flavor to your sandwich that you won't find anywhere else.
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 5 minutes
Total Time 10 minutes
Course Sandwich, Toppings
Cuisine American
Servings 4 people
Calories 125 kcal

Ingredients
  

  • Avocado
  • Crispy bacon
  • Pickled jalapenos
  • Red onion
  • Blue cheese
  • Sriracha mayo
  • Sliced tomatoes
  • Creamy ranch dressing
  • Caramelized onions
  • Cucumber slices

Instructions
 

  • Select your favorite toppings.
  • Prepare the rest of your tasty buffalo chicken sandwich.
  • Enjoy your meal in 20 minutes or less.
Website | + posts

Jenny has always been passionate about cooking, and she uses her platform to share her joy of food with others. Her recipes are easy to follow, and she loves giving tips and tricks to help others create their own unique culinary creations.