Skip to Content

What Cheese to Use for Chile Rellenos: 7 Best Cheeses

If you’re looking for the best kinds of cheese to use for spicing up your chile rellenos, look no further.

What Cheese to Use for Chile Rellenos

We’ve rounded up some of the most popular cheeses and analyzed them on a few different fronts so that you can make an informed decision about which kind is right for your recipe.

What Cheese to Use for Chile Rellenos?

The best cheese to use for chile rellenos is cotija. Cotija is a hard cow’s milk cheese that is dry and salty, which makes it a perfect complement to the spicy pepper in the dish. It also has a nice bite when melted, so it adds texture to the dish as well as flavor.

Chile Rellenos

The list below will take you through 13 of the best cheeses to use for chile rellenos.

Each cheese has its own unique flavor profile and texture, so consider this list your guide to finding the perfect one for your next chile relleno dish!

Monterey Jack

Monterey Jack

If you’re looking for a cheese that’s mild and buttery, Monterey Jack is a great choice for chile rellenos.

Monterey Jack is a white cheese made from cow’s milk in California.

It has a semi-hard texture and is known for its mild flavor and slight sweetness.

It also has a pale-yellow color and has a buttery flavor.

The best way to use this kind of cheese for chile rellenos is to grate it finely and add it directly to your dish while it’s still hot so that the cheese melts into the peppers perfectly.

Baby Swiss

Baby Swiss Cheese

Baby Swiss cheese is a great choice for chile rellenos because it has a smooth, creamy and milder taste than traditional swiss cheese.

It is made with cow’s milk, and originated in America.

Baby Swiss is also made in the style of traditional swiss cheese, which means that it has holes throughout it, but it is a little bit more flavorful than traditional swiss cheese.

Here are two tips for using Baby Swiss for your chile rellenos recipe:

  • Use fresh baby swiss instead of shredded to get the best flavor
  • You can also add some parmesan cheese if you want your dish to be bolder.


Cheddar Cheese

Cheddar is a natural English cheese that originates from the village of Cheddar in Somerset.

It is a hard English cheese with a sharp taste, and it comes in an orange color.

Cheddar is a relatively hard cheese and can be used for making chile rellenos. It’s best to use cheddar for this recipe because it’s already quite hard and won’t melt too much in the heat of the oven.

If you want to make chile rellenos with this kind of cheese, try adding some diced green peppers or jalapeños to the filling or topping your dish with breadcrumbs.


Mozzarella cheese

Mozzarella is a southern Italian cheese made from the milk of Italian buffalo.

It’s traditionally made using the pasta filata method, which means it’s kneaded and stretched to give it a delicate and slightly sour flavor.

The longer mozzarella ages, the softer and more sour it becomes.

But there’s no need to wait that long—you can use fresh mozzarella right away in your chile rellenos recipe for a balanced combination of textures and flavors.

Mozzarella is also low in calories compared to other cheeses: one hundred grams of mozzarella has only 280 calories!

Colby cheese

Colby Jack

Mozzarella is a semi-hard orange cheese that’s made from cow’s milk.

It was first developed in 1885 and named after the city of Colby, Wisconsin.

It’s a golden or orange color, and only aged for one to three months. The taste is lactic and mild, with a buttery finish.

You can use mozzarella in your chile rellenos recipe instead of cheddar or Monterey jack because it has such a mild flavor.

You’ll want to shred it into long strands, then coat them in an egg mixture before frying them up like an omelette.

You can also cut it into cubes and add it to the batter for frying.

If you’re using mozzarella for your chile rellenos recipe, make sure you cube it first so it will be easy to coat with batter before frying!



Gruyere is a hard Swiss cheese with a rich, creamy, salty and nutty flavor. It is usually aged for 12 months, though the flavor depends on age.

This type of cheese was first made in Switzerland but today it’s also produced in France and Italy.

Gruyere goes well with champagne and it has 413 calories per 100 grams (more than other cheeses).

It’s also an excellent choice for chile rellenos recipes because it melts well and has a subtle nutty flavor that pairs well with red chile sauce.

If you’re looking for a tasty way to add some extra flavor to your chile rellenos recipe, then consider using Gruyere!

Pepper Jack

Pepper Jack

Pepper jack cheese is a variant of Monterey Jack cheese that has a spicy flavor. Its texture is semi-soft and open, meaning it melts easily.

Related: 22 Pepper Jack Cheese Recipes I Can’t Resist

This cheese has a high moisture content, which also contributes to its melting properties.

Pepper jack is perfect for making chile rellenos because it melts so easily and has a spicy flavor that complements the chile peppers in the dish.

You can use pepper jack in other recipes as well, but if you want to make chile rellenos, it’s the perfect choice!

The first thing you should do when using this kind of cheese for a chile rellenos recipe is grate or crumble it into small pieces before adding it to your batter or filling mixture.

This will help distribute the flavor throughout your dish without making one area too salty or spicy.

Remember: Grating or crumbling it into small pieces before adding it to your batter or filling mixture will help distribute the flavor throughout your dish without making one area too salty or spicy.


What Cheese Goes Well with Clam Chowder? 10 Best Cheeses

What Cheese Goes on Caesar Salad? (12 Types of Cheese)

What Cheese Goes with Buffalo Chicken? (10 Best Cheeses)

What Cheese Goes in Chicken Alfredo? (9 Cheeses)

What Cheese Goes with Lamb Burgers? (11 Kinds of Cheese)

What Cheese Goes with Fish Tacos? 10 Best Cheeses

What Cheese to Use for Enchiladas (9 Best Cheeses)

What Cheese to Use for Quesadillas (23 Best Cheeses)

What Cheese Goes on A Philly Cheesesteak? (25 Cheeses)

What Cheese Goes Well with Salmon? 14 Best Cheeses

Chile Rellenos

What Cheese to Use for Chile Rellenos (7 Best Cheeses)

If you're looking to make a dish with cheese, you might be wondering what kind of cheese to use.
Well, we've got a few tips on how to decide what cheese to use for your next chile rellenos recipe!
1. Consider the texture
Chile rellenos are usually made with a mild cheese that won't overpower the other flavors in the dish. If you want something more flavorful and creamy, you can try adding queso fresco or asadero cheese.
2. Think about what will complement the chile relleno
If you're making chile rellenos with beef, consider using a sharper cheddar or jack cheese to balance out the meaty flavor of the meat. If you're making them with chicken, try using a milder cheddar instead so it doesn't clash with the savory chicken taste.
3. Think about whether or not you want red or white sauce
Red sauce goes better with white cheeses like queso blanco (we recommend trying either Asadero or Queso Fresco). White sauce goes better with red cheeses like Monterey Jack (try Cabrales if you want something really sharp).
Prep Time 3 minutes
Cook Time 3 minutes
Total Time 6 minutes
Course Cheese, Main Course
Cuisine Mexican
Servings 4 people
Calories 357 kcal


  • Monterey Jack
  • Baby Swiss
  • Cheddar
  • Mozzarella
  • Colby cheese
  • Gruyere
  • Pepper Jack


  • Pick your favorite kind of cheese from this list to use for your Chile Rellenos recipe.
  • Prepare the rest of your Mexican meal.
  • Be ready to munch in no time!
Keyword What Cheese to Use for Chile Rellenos