Skip to Content

Old-Fashioned Macaroni and Cheese Recipe

Exploring the world of comfort food, the Old-Fashioned Macaroni and Cheese recipe emerges as a timeless classic. Its creamy interior and golden crust offer a taste of nostalgia, uniting generations.

This beloved dish, a blend of simplicity and perfection, warms hearts and kitchens alike, proving the enduring charm of traditional flavors.

What To Serve With Mac and Cheese – 30 Best Side Dishes

Crockpot Mac and Cheese without Evaporated Milk

The 5 Best Kinds of Pasta for Lobster Mac and Cheese

Old-Fashioned Macaroni and Cheese

comforting classic macaroni dish

When it comes to comfort food, nothing beats the good old mac and cheese. It’s like a warm hug in a dish, simple yet so satisfying. It brings back those happy vibes from family meals and chill evenings.

Making it’s like taking a trip down memory lane to when things were simpler. From boiling the pasta to stirring in that gooey cheese sauce, it’s almost like a mini escape. Every step, even just buttering the baking dish and waiting for that golden crust, is all worth it.

Eating it’s as heartwarming as making it.

Ingredients You’ll Need (+ Possible Substitutes)

Let’s dive into the cozy world of classic mac and cheese and round up everything we need to whip up this ultimate comfort dish.

What You’ll Need:

  • 4 cups of elbow macaroni, already cooked ’til just right
  • 2 tablespoons of butter to make it oh-so-creamy
  • 1 1/2 cups of shredded mild cheddar cheese for that cheesy pull
  • Just a dash of salt and pepper, let’s say about 1/2 teaspoon of salt and a sprinkle (1/4 teaspoon) of pepper, to taste

Got No This? Try That!:

  • No elbow macaroni in the pantry? No stress. Any small pasta shape will get the job done.
  • Fancy shaking things up? Throw in a mix of cheeses like mozzarella or Gouda for a fun twist.
  • If dairy’s not your friend, no worries. There are plenty of non-dairy milk and cheese swaps out there, just keep in mind the flavor might change a bit.

How To Make It

crafting a successful project

How can we whip up a cozy dish from just a few basic things? It’s surprisingly simple! Here’s my go-to method:

  1. Get Ready: First, I heat the oven up to 350 degrees Fahrenheit and give a 1.5-quart baking dish a little grease-up. Butter’s my top pick for this, but if you’re in a hurry, cooking spray totally works too.
  2. Mix It Up: In that greased dish, I throw together the cooked elbow macaroni, a good dollop of butter, some yummy mild cheddar cheese, a pinch of salt, and a dash of pepper. This mix is the heart of our dish.
  3. Bake Time: Next, I beat together some eggs and milk, then drizzle it all over the mac and cheese mix. Popping it in the oven for 40 to 50 minutes does the trick, turning it all golden and mouth-wateringly bubbly.

And there you have it!

Tips For Success

Wanna nail that homemade mac and cheese? Trust me, I’ve got some tricks up my sleeve that’ll make your dish the talk of the town.

First off, don’t even think about using that cheap cheese. Splurge a little on the good stuff, especially a nice mild cheddar. It melts like a dream and tastes like heaven.

Also, when you’re boiling your macaroni, cut the cooking time short. It keeps cooking in the oven, and we’re not aiming for mush city.

Now, when you’re mixing eggs and milk, go at it until it’s super smooth – we’re talking about getting that sauce silky and perfectly mixed.

And here’s a little patience test – let that golden beauty sit for a bit after it comes out of the oven. It lets the sauce get all thick and gooey, making every bite pure bliss.

Serving Suggestions

creative ways to serve

Kick your mac and cheese game up a notch by picking the perfect partners in crime for it. After nailing that oh-so-gooey, soul-hugging bowl of cheesy goodness, I’ve found that the sidekicks you choose can seriously up the ante. Here are my go-to picks:

  1. A Zesty Green Salad: Just toss together some greens and a punchy vinaigrette. It’s like a fresh breeze that cuts right through the mac and cheese’s cozy hug, giving you the best of both worlds.
  2. Crunchy Green Buddies – Steamed Broccoli or Roasted Brussels Sprouts: These green machines aren’t just about adding color to your plate. They bring a crunch and a pinch of health, making you feel a tad less guilty about diving into that cheesy coma.
  3. A Chill Sip – Apple Cider or Chardonnay: Whether you’re team no-alcohol or have a soft spot for a glass of wine, both these drinks are like the cool new friends that get along with everyone, especially your mac and cheese.

Mixing and matching these with your mac and cheese isn’t just about eating; it’s about crafting a meal that makes you wanna pat yourself on the back.

Storing, Freezing & Reheating

After you’ve nailed the perfect sides to go with your mac and cheese, it’s key to know how to keep those cheesy leftovers tasting fresh. My trick? Let it cool down, then pop it into a snug container. It’ll be your fridge’s best pal for three to five days.

If you’re thinking long-term, like saving some for that Netflix binge next month, freeze it in portions. Wrap them up tight, and they’re good for a cool three months.

When it’s time to dive back in, reheating is a piece of cake. I’m all about that oven method to keep the top crunchy. Just cover it with some foil and heat it at 350 degrees until it’s warm and bubbly. That way, not a single spoonful of that creamy, cheesy magic goes to waste.

CEO at Happy Muncher | benjamin@happymuncher.com | Website | + posts

Hi, I'm Benjamin. I love cooking, long walks, and my girlfriend! Here you’ll find simple and delicious recipes that you can make in 30 minutes or less.