Skip to Content

Cookie Frosting Recipe

Watch the video below for the recipe.

Imagine finding the perfect sugar cookie icing. It not only tastes great but makes cookie making special. I found this joy at 12, thanks to Leigh Anne Wilkes. Her homemade frosting is more than topping; it’s special.

Cookie Frosting Recipe

Every time I make it, I feel happy. Mixing butter, sugar, and vanilla feels right. It’s not just good icing; it’s tradition in every bite. Watch the video below to see how it’s made.

Ingredients for a Perfect Cookie Frosting

Getting the best cookie frosting starts with great ingredients. Leigh Anne Wilkes says using quality butter is crucial. It should be soft for a smooth taste. If the butter is unsalted, a bit of salt helps the flavor.

Confectioners’ sugar, or powdered sugar, is a must-have. It makes the frosting smooth and lumps-free. Adding just a little milk or cream makes it just right. For a rich taste, you need pure vanilla extract. If you want bright frosting, use clear vanilla. Gel food coloring gives the best colors without changing the frosting’s texture.

Another baker, Sally, gives a simple way to make cookie icing. It uses water, corn syrup, and a bit of salt. This mixture is thick and shiny. It works well for both taste and looks. You can easily stack cookies with this frosting.

“Real, high-quality ingredients make all the difference in perfecting your cookie frosting,” says Leigh Anne Wilkes. “From softened butter to pure vanilla extract, this careful selection helps create frosting that’s not just tasty but also easy to work with.”

Step-by-Step Guide to Making Cookie Frosting

The key to start making cookie frosting is using soft butter. Add the sugar slowly to avoid lumps. Mix in some milk or cream carefully for the right thickness.

Add pure vanilla extract next to make it taste great. You can also use flavors like almond, peppermint, or lemon to make it your own.

To color your frosting, use gel food colors. Split the frosting into bowls before coloring. Keep an eye on the texture and avoid over-beating. Always use the frosting warm; bring it to room temperature if it’s been in the fridge.

If your frosting is too thin, add more sugar. If too thick, add milk. Try Sally’s method: whisk thick parts first and add water slowly. This will make your sugar cookie decorating frosting just right.

Learning how to make frosting is about these little changes. Be patient, and your cookies will taste amazing and look beautiful. Happy baking!

Tips for Decorating and Storing Cookie Frosting

Decorating cookies can be an art form. The key is using the right techniques and tools. Try using a squeeze bottle or piping tips for precision and ease. This works for both complex designs and simple outlines.

When adding sprinkles, do it while the frosting is wet. This helps them stick better. If you use liquid food coloring, add it first to keep the right texture.

Storing frosting well is crucial. After refrigerating, let it warm up to room temperature. Adjust its thickness with milk or powdered sugar.

Remember, icing colors get darker as they dry. Add food coloring little by little. Keep the frosting in an airtight container in the fridge for up to two days.

These tips help you make great-looking cookies. By choosing the right tools and keeping the frosting just right, your cookies will be tasty and beautiful.


What ingredients do I need for the best cookie frosting?

Start with high-quality, soft butter and powdered sugar. Add milk or cream and pure vanilla extract. Use almond, peppermint, or lemon if you want. If you plan to color it, use gel food coloring. It makes colors vibrant. For a simple icing, mix water and corn syrup with a bit of salt.

How do I achieve the perfect consistency for cookie frosting?

First, cream the butter well. Add the powdered sugar slowly. Then, add milk or cream little by little. Keep going until it’s easy to spread. If it’s too thin, add more sugar. If it’s too thick, add more milk.

Can I use regular butter or is high-quality butter necessary?

High-quality, real butter is best for taste and texture. If it’s unsalted, add a bit of salt for flavor.

How should I add food coloring to my cookie frosting?

Put frosting in bowls. Add gel color to each. With liquid color, mix it first with other liquids. The colors might get deeper as they dry.

What’s the best way to store cookie frosting?

If you keep it in the fridge, let it warm to room temp before using. Adjust with milk or sugar if needed. For longer storage, refrigerate for up to two days. Cover it well to avoid drying.

Can I add sprinkles or other decorations to the frosting?

Yes, add sprinkles when the frosting is still wet. They’ll stick better. Use squeeze bottles or piping tips for more precise designs.

How do I avoid introducing too much air into the frosting?

Don’t beat the frosting too much. Overmixing could add too much air. Mix until you have a smooth mix.

Can I use different extracts for flavoring the frosting?

Sure, you can make your frosting special with different extracts. Try almond, peppermint, orange, or lemon for unique flavors.

Source Links

Jenny has always been passionate about cooking, and she uses her platform to share her joy of food with others. Her recipes are easy to follow, and she loves giving tips and tricks to help others create their own unique culinary creations.