Skip to Content

16 Best Pulled Chicken Sandwich Toppings

A pulled chicken sandwich is a delicious and easy way to enjoy chicken.

You can use any type of chicken you like, but the best chicken for a pulled sandwich is cooked until it is tender and juicy.

Once your chicken is cooked, all you need to do is shred it and add your favorite toppings.

There are many different ways you can top off a pulled chicken sandwich. Some people like to keep it simple with just chicken and BBQ sauce, while others like to pile on the toppings. Popular toppings include coleslaw, onions, green peppers, cheese, bacon, and avocado.

Pulled Chicken Sandwich Toppings

If you are looking for some inspiration for your next pulled chicken sandwich, look no further!

This list includes some of the best pulled chicken sandwich toppings from around the web.

16 Best Pulled Chicken Sandwich Toppings

Pulled Chicken Sandwich
Source: tasteofhome.com

There’s nothing quite like a pulled chicken sandwich.

It’s the perfect balance of savory and sweet, with a texture that’s both juicy and tender.

But what to put on it?

Here are 16 of the best toppings for pulled chicken sandwiches:

1. BBQ Sauce

BBQ Sauce
Source: addapinch.com

BBQ sauce adds a flavor that no other sauce can quite replicate.

It has a smoky, slightly sweet, and tangy taste that is perfect for pulled chicken sandwiches.

The sauce is also thick enough to coat the chicken and add some extra flavor and moisture to the sandwich.

Other ingredients that pair well with BBQ sauce include onions, pickles, cheese, and bacon.

These toppings can all be added to the sandwich to create a more complex and delicious flavor profile.

Preparing BBQ sauce is simple and only requires a few ingredients.

Most BBQ sauces are made with ketchup, vinegar, sugar, and spices.

These ingredients are combined and cooked until the sauce is thick and flavorful.

2. Honey Mustard

Honey Mustard
Source: thenovicechefblog.com

The sweet taste of honey mustard is a perfect compliment to the savory flavors of pulled chicken.

This topping is also great for adding a little bit of extra crunch to your sandwich.

Try pairing it with other ingredients like lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise for a delicious and easy to make sandwich.

3. Buffalo Sauce

Buffalo Sauce
Source: therecipecritic.com

Buffalo sauce and chicken go hand-in-hand.

The sauce is thick and tangy, with a little bit of spice. It’s the perfect complement to the rich, juicy flavor of chicken.

Other ingredients that pair well with buffalo sauce include blue cheese, celery, and carrots.

Preparing this topping is simple: just mix buffalo sauce with cooked chicken.

You can also add a little bit of blue cheese dressing to the mixture, if you like.

4. Jalapeños

Jalapeños slices

If you’re the kind of person who likes some spice in their life, then jalapeños are the perfect topping for your pulled chicken sandwich.

Jalapeños add a nice kick of heat and flavor to the sandwich, and they also pair well with other ingredients like cheese and sour cream.

To prepare your jalapeños, simply slice them up into thin pieces and add them to your sandwich.

5. Anchovies

Anchovies

Alright, this won’t be everybody’s favorite pulled chicken sandwich topping, but hear me out.

I’m a big fan of anchovies.

I know they can be super salty, but I love the umami flavor they add to a dish.

And on a pulled chicken sandwich, they add a nice depth of flavor.

Now, as for the texture, anchovies can be a bit slimy.

But I think that’s part of their charm.

And when paired with other ingredients, like a crispy onion or a tangy BBQ sauce, they can really elevate a dish.

If you’re interested in trying anchovies on your next pulled chicken sandwich, I would recommend preparing them by mincing them up.

This way, you’ll get a little bit of flavor in every bite.

Trust me, it’s worth it.

6. Pineapple

Pineapple slices

Pineapple adds a delicious sweet and tangy flavor to pulled chicken sandwiches.

This fruit pairs well with other tropical fruits, like mango and papaya.

It’s also delicious with a spicy kick, like jalapeño peppers.

To prepare pineapple, simply remove the skin and core. Then, cut it into small pieces or slices.

Once you’ve added pineapple to your pulled chicken sandwich, enjoy the amazing flavor combination!

7. Ham

Ham

Why not add some more protein to your sandwich by slicing up some ham?

Ham has a distinctively salty flavor that can really liven up a sandwich.

It’s also quite chewy, so it can add some nice texture.

Try pairing ham with other strong flavors like sharp cheese or pickles.

As for prep, just slice up some ham thin and lay it on top of your pulled chicken sandwich.

8. Roast Beef

Roast Beef

Personally, I love protein, and what could be more packed with protein than roast beef?

This topping is perfect for anyone looking for a hearty, filling sandwich.

The beef is juicy and has a great savory flavor that pairs well with other ingredients like cheese and BBQ sauce.

To prepare this topping, simply cook up some roast beef and add it to your sandwich.

9. Turkey Breast

Turkey

Most people think that you can’t add another protein to a pulled chicken sandwich, but turkey breast makes an excellent addition.

It has a similar texture to chicken, but a slightly different flavor that can really complement the other ingredients in the sandwich.

Turkey breast also pairs well with other toppings like avocado, bacon, and cheese.

To prepare this topping, simply cook the turkey breast in the oven or on the stove until it is cooked through.

Then, shred it with a fork or chop it into small pieces.

10. Blue Cheese Dressing

This dressing has a flavor that is hard to describe, but it is perfect for pulled chicken sandwiches.

The dressing is thick and creamy, with a strong blue cheese flavor.

Other ingredients that pair well with this dressing include bacon, lettuce, and tomato.

To prepare this dressing, simply combine all of the ingredients in a bowl and mix until smooth.

11. Caesar Dressing

Caesar Salad Dressing

One of the things I love about caesar dressing is its creamy texture.

It’s thick and coats the chicken well, but it’s not too heavy.

The taste is savory and slightly acidic, with a hint of garlic and anchovy.

I think it pairs well with other strong flavors, like bacon or blue cheese.

To prepare caesar dressing, you’ll need some mayonnaise, garlic, anchovy paste, Parmesan cheese, lemon juice, and black pepper.

Just mix all the ingredients together and you’re good to go!

12. Ranch Dressing

Ranch Dressing

Why not add some ranch dressing to your sandwich?

It’s creamy and tangy, and goes great with other sandwich toppings like lettuce, tomato, and onion.

Plus, it’s easy to prepare – just mix together some mayonnaise, sour cream, and spices.

13. Tomato Slices

Tomato Slices

No sandwich is complete without tomatoes!

They add a juicy, fresh flavor that takes any sandwich to the next level.

Plus, their bright red color is always a welcome addition to any meal.

When it comes to texture, tomatoes are firm but also have a bit of give to them.

This makes them the perfect addition to a pulled chicken sandwich, as they won’t fall apart when you take a bite.

As for flavor, tomatoes are slightly acidic and sweet, which pairs perfectly with the savory flavor of chicken.

Other ingredients that go well with tomatoes on a pulled chicken sandwich include lettuce, onions, and pickles.

All of these ingredients add a crunch that compliments the juiciness of the tomatoes.

As for preparation, simply slice a tomato or two into thin pieces and add to your sandwich.

14. Pickles

Pickles

Pickles, you either love them or hate them.

I’m one of those people who love them.

I love the crunchy texture and the sour, salty taste.

They pair well with other sandwich toppings like cheese, lettuce, and tomato.

You can find pickles already prepared and ready to eat at most grocery stores.

15. Arugula

Arugula

Arugula tastes sort of like a cross between cabbage and spinach, and has a slightly peppery flavor.

It’s a great way to add some extra nutrition and flavor to your pulled chicken sandwich.

Arugula pairs well with other leafy greens like spinach or lettuce, as well as with crunchy vegetables like carrots or celery.

To prepare arugula, simply wash it and chop it into bite-sized pieces.

16. Lettuce

Lettuce

If you like some crunch in your pulled chicken sandwich, then lettuce is a great option.

It has a refreshingly crisp texture that pairs well with the moist chicken.

Plus, it’s a healthy way to add some volume to your sandwich.

Just make sure to chop it up into small pieces so it doesn’t overpower the other flavors.

Pulled Chicken Sandwich Toppings

16 Best Pulled Chicken Sandwich Toppings

Chicken sandwiches are a lunchtime staple, but sometimes it can be hard to come up with new and interesting ways to dress them up.
This list of 16 best pulled chicken sandwich toppings is the perfect solution for when you're in a lunch rut.
From traditional BBQ sauce to unexpected options like mango salsa, there's something on this list for everyone.
And because most of these toppings can be made ahead of time, you can easily whip up a delicious sandwich in no time.
So next time you're looking for a quick and easy lunch option, reach for this list and get inspired.
Prep Time 2 mins
Cook Time 2 mins
Total Time 4 mins
Course Sandwich, Toppings
Cuisine American
Servings 4 people
Calories 41 kcal

Ingredients
  

  • BBQ Sauce
  • Honey Mustard
  • Buffalo Sauce
  • Jalapeños
  • Anchovies
  • Pineapple
  • Ham
  • Roast Beef
  • Turkey Breast
  • Blue Cheese Dressing
  • Caesar Dressing
  • Ranch Dressing
  • Tomato Slices
  • Pickles
  • Arugula
  • Lettuce

Instructions
 

  • Pick your favorite toppings from this list to put on your pulled chicken sandwich.
  • Prepare the rest of your delicious meal.
  • Enjoy in no time!
Keyword Pulled Chicken Sandwich Toppings