Skip to Content

25 Best Crab Cake Sandwich Toppings

Are you looking for a delicious way to top off your crab cake sandwich?

From crispy lettuce and juicy tomatoes, to creamy avocado and tangy mustard, the possibilities are endless!

But if you are searching for crab cake sandwich toppings that will really take your dinner up a notch, then you are in the right place.

I’m sharing 25 of the best toppings for crab cakes sandwiches including sauces, vegetables, herbs, and more.

So get ready to make your next crab cake sandwich even tastier.

Read Also: The 10 Best Wines To Pair With Crab Cakes

Crab Cake Sandwich

25 Best Crab Cake Sandwich Toppings

Crab cake sandwiches are a delicious meal, but the toppings can make or break the dish.

Here is a list of 25 topping ideas for your crab cake sandwich that will take it to the next level:

1. Crispy Lettuce


A sandwich isn’t complete without some crunchy greens, and lettuce adds the perfect texture to your crab cake sandwich. Get ready for a flavor-packed bite of deliciousness – with juicy tomatoes and creamy avo, the combo is unbeatable!

2. Juicy Tomatoes

Tomato Slices

Tomatoes can be so finicky when it comes to sandwiches, but they add just the right sweetness and juiciness that your crab cake needs. Plus, you can use any variety you like – cherry tomatoes are delicious too!

3. Creamy Avocado


This one goes out to all the avocado lovers in the house – if you want to take your crab cake sandwich up a notch, then adding a spoonful of creamy avocado is definitely the way to go! Its rich flavor pairs perfectly with all those other ingredients, creating an addictively tasty experience from start to finish.

4. Tangy Mustard

This classic condiment gives your crab cake sandwich a delicious dimension of flavor that is sure to leave you wanting more. It’s like an old friend that always knows just how to make you feel better!

5. Spicy Sriracha

A spicy blast for your taste buds, this signature sauce will take your crab cake sandwich over the top. It offers up a zesty kick and its eye-watering heat will keep you coming back for more.

6. Pickled Onions

The perfect marriage between sweet and tangy, these deliciously tart onions add complexity to your crab cake sandwich while cutting through some of its richness at the same time. They are like the strong silent type – they don’t say much but their presence always leaves an impact!

7. Crispy Bacon

Holy moly! Sweet and salty, crunchy and chewy – bacon is the perfect topping for your crab cake sandwich. It’s like taking a bite of decadence with every single bite. Plus it smells amazing – what more could you want?!

8. Fresh Cilantro


This zesty herb adds a bright kick of flavor to any dish and this sandwich is no exception. Get some freshly picked cilantro leaves for extra freshness, then sprinkle them on top to add an exciting burst of flavor that will make your taste buds sing with delight!

9. Sliced Jalapeños

Jalapeños slices

Adding sliced jalapeños takes this crab cake sandwich from mild to wild in just one bite! There’s nothing quite like that comforting heat from jalapeño peppers that makes your mouth water (and maybe even shed a tear or two!). But trust me, it’s worth it for the sheer deliciousness factor alone.

10. Zesty Lemon Aioli

This zesty lemon aioli is like sunshine in a jar – bright, refreshing, and flavorful. It packs just the right amount of punch to make your crab cake sandwich sing with flavor. Try squeezing some fresh lemon juice on top for an extra zing!

11. Caramelized Onions

The sweet and savory aroma of caramelized onions can add depth and complexity to any dish, including your trusty crab cake sandwich. The mere smell will have your mouth watering in anticipation for that first bite. Go ahead, indulge yourself!

12. Creamy Coleslaw

Coleslaw may be considered traditional picnic fare, but it’s anything but boring when added to a crab cake sandwich. Its subtle sweetness adds balance and contrasts perfectly with the salty richness of the grilled seafood patty – addictive perfection!

13. Smoky Chipotle Sauce

This smoky and spicy sauce will send your crab cake sandwich over the top. It’s like a roundhouse kick from heaven that knocks your senses off their feet. The combination of smoke and heat flips the flavor switch in all the right ways, adding an element of adventure to your lunchtime meal.

14. Sweet Mango Salsa

A sweet and tangy treat, mango salsa adds its unique flair to any crab cake sandwich. Its bright and herbal flavors are so delectable it’s like having a tropical vacation with every bite – no plane ticket required! Paired with fresh greens or cilantro for extra zing, this topping is sure to make you swoon.

15. Tartar Sauce

Give your sandwich an old-fashioned twist by topping it with tartar sauce! This creamy condiment blends earthy notes of capers, parsley, and pickles into a delightful masterpiece that’ll leave you smiling ear-to-ear – the perfect addition to classic comfort food without ever straying too far away from traditionally delicious flavors.

16. Grilled Pineapple

This deliciously sweet topping will transform your crab cake sandwich into a tropical oasis. The smoky, caramelized flavors of the grilling process pair perfectly with the juicy pineapple to create an unbelievably tasty combination. Reefer madness has never been this good!

17. Crumbled Feta Cheese

Crumbled Feta Cheese

This tangy topping pairs wonderfully with the savory flavor of crab cakes and adds a wonderful texture contrast to each bite of your sandwich. Try it grilled and melted for an even more delicious finish!

18. Fried Egg

Nothing quite says comfort food like a fried egg on top of your crab cake sandwich – yum! It creates a luxuriously creamy sauce that goes together perfectly with all those other ingredients, plus it adds lots of protein and iron too. Now that’s what I call breakfast-lunch fusion tacos!

19. Arugula


This peppery green packs a flavorful punch that will add a nice flavor to your crab cake sandwich. Arugula is rich in Vitamin K, and its peppery taste pairs perfectly with the sweetness of crab cakes. It’s like a refreshing splash of water on your tongue – you’ll never want to go back!

20. Roasted Red Peppers

A bite into this sweet and smoky topping and you’ll be transported to flavor town! Sweet roasted red peppers pair beautifully with crab cakes and bring an extra layer of flavor that can’t be beaten. Plus, their vibrant hue makes for an eye-catching sight when layered atop your sandwiches.

21. Horseradish Sauce

Now here’s a condiment for those who aren’t afraid of taking risks! This spicy sauce will give you that little kick needed to put complex flavors at the forefront of your sandwich game. The tanginess from horseradish adds some needed zest while its bitterness perfectly counterbalances the sweetness from the crab cakes – making it one dynamite topping choice!

22. Old Bay Seasoning

This delicious spice blend with its signature notes of savory and smoky flavors will make your crab cake sandwich sing. Just a sprinkle of Old Bay before grilling or baking the cakes and you’ll have an explosion of flavor in every bite. Your tummy will thank you for it!

23. Red Onion Slices

red onion

Nothing adds a little sparkle to something like onions do – literally! If you want to add some crunch plus pizzazz to your crabby creation, then red onion slices are just what you need. Plus, they provide loads of nutrition too!

24. Creamy Remoulade Sauce

Rich and decadent, this sauce deserves a special place among all condiments for sure! With its paprika kick it takes these already amazing tasting bursts of flavor to next level perfection – one dip in this creamy pool of goodness and everything else fades away – trust me on that one.. And don’t forget to share the love with plenty of leftovers as there won’t be any complaints here at least.

25. Crispy Fried Pickles

Ahh…the sights, smells…and let’s not forget those heavenly fried pickle sounds too when dipping them into bubbling hot oil – that can only mean comfort food heaven right? Well, these zesty accompaniments will top off your crab cake sandwiches fabulously – salty meets sweet with great texture & taste domination all around the plate delightedly scoring high points everywhere.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, crab cakes make for a delicious and satisfying sandwich. To make your sandwich even more delicious, there are many different toppings that can be added to enhance the flavor.

The best toppings for a crab cake sandwich are crispy lettuce, juicy tomatoes, creamy avocado, tangy mustard, spicy sriracha, pickled onions, crispy bacon, fresh cilantro, sliced jalapeños, zesty lemon aioli, caramelized onions, creamy coleslaw, and smoky chipotle sauce.

These toppings are sure to take your sandwich to the next level, adding flavor and texture to each bite. So, the next time you make a crab cake sandwich, don’t forget to top it off with some of these delicious toppings.

Crab Cake Sandwich

25 Best Crab Cake Sandwich Toppings

If you're looking for a delicious and unique way to enjoy crab cakes, look no further! In this article, I'm sharing my top 25 crab cake sandwich toppings. From classic combinations like tartar sauce to more creative toppings like pesto and salsa, I'll provide you with plenty of ideas to make your next crab cake sandwich the best one yet.
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 5 minutes
Total Time 10 minutes
Course Sandwich, Toppings
Cuisine American
Servings 4 people
Calories 311 kcal


  • Crispy Lettuce
  • Juicy Tomatoes
  • Creamy Avocado
  • Tangy Mustard
  • Spicy Sriracha
  • Pickled Onions
  • Crispy Bacon
  • Fresh Cilantro
  • Sliced Jalapeños
  • Zesty Lemon Aioli
  • Caramelized Onions
  • Creamy Coleslaw
  • Smoky Chipotle Sauce
  • Sweet Mango Salsa
  • Tartar Sauce
  • Grilled Pineapple
  • Crumbled Feta Cheese
  • Fried Egg
  • Arugula
  • Roasted Red Peppers
  • Horseradish Sauce
  • Old Bay Seasoning
  • Red Onion Slices
  • Creamy Remoulade Sauce
  • Crispy Fried Pickles


  • Select your favorite crab cake sandwich toppings from this article.
  • Prepare the toppings according to your preference.
  • Prep your sandwich in 30 minutes or less.
jenny happy muncher
 | Website

Jenny has always been passionate about cooking, and she uses her platform to share her joy of food with others. Her recipes are easy to follow, and she loves giving tips and tricks to help others create their own unique culinary creations.