Skip to Content

How to Reheat Levain Cookies: The Ultimate Guide

Levain cookies are one of the most popular treats out there, and for good reason.

They’re buttery, gooey, and have a slightly crispy exterior that’s hard to resist.

But what do you do when you have leftover levain cookies that need reheating?

Do you simply pop them in the microwave and hope for the best?

Contrary to popular belief, not all reheating methods work well with levain cookies.

In this post, we’ll go through different ways of reheating these delicious baked goods.

We’ll also cover why proper reheating is essential in maintaining their original taste and texture.

How to Reheat Levain Cookies

Why Proper Reheating of Levain Cookies Is Important

Before we dive into how-to’s, let’s discuss why it’s crucial to reheat levain cookies correctly.

When baked goods such as cookies get cold or sit around for too long without proper storage, they lose their original texture and moisture.

It makes them less desirable as they become hard instead of soft.

This condition applies mostly if you leave these baked products out in the open exposed to air.

Reheating helps restore some of that lost moisture while bringing back the cookie’s original texture – warm and gooey on the inside with crispy edges.

Proper heating ensures that your beloved levain cookies taste just as good as they did when fresh out-of-the-oven.

How To Reheat Levain Cookies in The Oven

Now let’s talk about one of the most effective ways to reheat levain cookies – using an oven! This method guarantees your cookie maintains its goodness while restoring its texture.


Using an oven is considered by many baking experts as the best way to reheat levain cookies since it produces even heat distribution compared to other methods.

While this method may take a little more time than others we’re goingto cover but results in a more consistent heating throughout the cookie, ensuring that every bite is the same warm and gooey feeling as before.


The oven requires some planning, and reheating takes longer. You may also be wary of leaving the oven running if you’re busy with other tasks.

Also, there’s a risk of overcooking or drying out the cookies when not monitored closely – this may lead to hard, crumbly cookies that won’t taste good.

To reheat your levain cookies in an oven:

  1. Preheat your oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit.
  2. Place your leftover levain cookies on an ungreased cookie sheet.
  3. Cover the cookie sheet with aluminum foil to prevent the very top from getting too crispy.
  4. Bake in the preheated oven for around 5 minutes for freshly baked quality texture or 10 minutes if you prefer a crispy exterior.
  5. Once heated thoroughly, take them out of the oven and let them cool down for some time before serving.

How To Reheat Levain Cookies on The Stove

Using this method offers more control to avoid overcooking or burning your delicious cookies while reheating quickly.


This method is quicker than using an oven and offers more control over how much heat goes into each cookie lying directly on a griddle pan allowing individual heating per flipped side – so no crunchy parts are left out!


It’s not useful when you have a busy schedule since attention is required throughout reheating – Depending on improper use or attentiveness one can end up burning their beloved goods or ending up with dryness at times, leaving unenjoyable textures.

To reheat your Levain Cookies using an open griddle:

  1. Heat up your griddle pan over low heat until well heated (but not smoking hot).
  2. Drop some butter (or margarine) onto the griddle pan – enough to coat the pan.
  3. Place the leftover levain cookies on top of the melted butter, with some adequate spacing between each cookie.
  4. Use medium heat to warm them up slowly until slightly crisp for optimal texture.
  5. Keep repeating turn over every fifteen seconds till fully heated without burning each side.

How To Reheat Levain Cookies in The Microwave

Microwaving can be a convenient and fast way of reheating baked goods when in a hurry or have only a few left for it’s ease of use.


The microwave is very efficient for this task since it reheats your baked treats almost instantly, making it perfect for those with busy schedules or no time to wait.


Baked items heated using this method are more likely to dry out as microwaving produces uneven heat distribution; thus, some spots may become hard while other parts remain cold while attempting optimal heating time resulting in possibly mushy/soggy sweets.

To reheat your levain cookies using this short-cut method:

  1. Transfer your leftover levain cookies onto a microwave-safe plate.
  2. Cover each cookie with a damp paper towel before putting them into the microwave oven if possible.
  3. Remove any excess moisture by pounding firmly over the paper towel surface
  4. Heat on medium power settings under 10 seconds at a time till fully heated through (approximately two repetitions should suffice).
  5. Take care not to burn yourself when taking them out—Remember, microwaved items tend to be hot on the inside due to internal steam accumulation!

How To Reheat Levain Cookies in An Air Fryer

The air fryer quickly became one of my go-to useful appliances because they’re compact and speedily prepare meals quickly while heating evenly compared to traditional ovens.


The air fryer is an excellent option because you will achieve similar effects to using an oven but with better heat distribution. It won’t require preheating, and you can use it for other menu options with low oil usage.


This method would not be useful if you don’t have an air fryer at home.

To reheat levain cookies in an air fryer:

  1. Set the air fryer temperature between 350 degrees Fahrenheit – 375 °F
  2. Arrange your leftover levain cookies inside the basket, making sure they have a little space between them.
  3. Cook each side for approximately two minutes, but check regularly until they reach optimal texture.
  4. Take care not to press too hard when removing them from the Air Fryer basket as this may cause cracking on cookies surfaces.

How To Reheat Levain Cookies in A Toaster Oven

A toaster oven is a great appliance that provides quick and convenient heating options ideal for small quantities reheating purposes such as our beloved cookies.


This method uses lesser electricity consumption than a conventional oven, and there’s no necessity to preheat first; therefore efficient when providing instant results.


The toaster’s limited size means you can only reheat a minimal amount at once leaving most times fewer quantities left uneaten refrigerated in rush hours or busy days!

To reheat levain cookies in a toaster oven:

  1. Adjust its setting knob temperature to 350 degrees Fahrenheit — Check manufactures instruction while defrosting just within room temperature advises on package instruction evenly or preferred temperatures.
  2. Place leftovers evenly spaced out onto the tray, ensuring equal exposure per finger-shaped treat.
  3. Heat until heated through (about five minutes) monitor closely during these minutes since smaller items tend to overcook easily in these appliances.
  4. Reduce time if almost becoming crispy knowing each model differs by preference per cookie batches – note down the settings that worked best!

Is It Safe To Reheat Levain Cookies?

It’s safe to reheat levain cookies if you follow the proper steps and tips catered to each reheating method while storing leftover dough in wraps/containers according to manufacture instructions, and understanding each time differences that may occur with various batches.

Suppose, you happen to notice any form of mold growth or an unusual smell coming from your dessert treat, discard them immediately.


Reheating leftover levain cookies can be either a daunting task or a quick way of satisfying your sweet tooth cravings.

The best way to do so is by ensuring you’re using the right method per appliance available, as some methods tend to dry out or overcook baked items if not followed correctly.

These last points with good cookie dough storage will provide anyone who has leftovers peace of mind knowing how restoring awaits.

We hope our guide provides a great experience that showcases why it’s essential to warm up those biscuits properly!

jenny happy muncher
 | Website

Jenny has always been passionate about cooking, and she uses her platform to share her joy of food with others. Her recipes are easy to follow, and she loves giving tips and tricks to help others create their own unique culinary creations.