If you love the taste of Reddi Whip, it’s probably because you grew up eating it.
And if you’re like most people, you probably used it for more than just topping off your favorite dessert!
After all, there are lots of ways to use this well-loved whipped cream.
In this article, we’ll answer the question: can you substitute Reddi Whip for Cool Whip in a recipe?
Can You Use Reddi Whip Instead of Cool Whip in A Recipe?
Absolutely, you can use Reddi whip instead of cool whip in your recipes!
Reddi whip is essentially a whipped cream that comes in a can.
It’s conveniently pre-whipped, and it tastes and behaves a lot like real whipped cream.
Cool whip, on the other hand, is more of a dessert topping.
It tastes more artificial and has more stabilizers than real whipped cream.
Both Reddi whip and cool whip are great for recipes where you need spreadable whipped cream that maintains its shape, like on cakes or pies.
So if your recipe calls for either one, you can definitely use the other as an alternative.
But if you’re looking for something with a more natural taste and texture, consider whipping your own heavy cream at home!
How to Use Reddi Whip Instead of Cool Whip in A Recipe
- Take the Reddi Whip out of the fridge or freezer and let it stand at room temperature for 10 minutes. Make sure there is enough time for the Reddi Whip to fully thaw.
- Use a mixer (or even a fork) to whip the Reddi Whip so that it is light and fluffy. It should be about twice as fluffy as when you first took it out of the fridge or freezer.
- Add any additional ingredients required by your recipe.
Your Cool Whip substitute is ready for use in whatever recipe you need it for!
What Is the Difference Between Cool Whip and Reddi Whip?
Many people confuse cool whip with Reddi whip, which is an actual product on the market.
But really, cool whip and Reddi whip are two different things.
Cool whip is actually just whipped cream mixed with artificial sweetener and then frozen.
You can find it in the freezer section of your grocery store, usually near the ice cream.
Reddy Whip is real butter mixed with real sugar and real eggs—it’s the ultimate in comfort food, and is usually found in the dairy aisle at your grocery store.
So what’s the difference?
Well, cool whip doesn’t have any flavor or color added to it; it’s just plain old whipped cream (which tastes delicious).
Reddi whip doesn’t have any sugar or eggs added; it’s just pure butter whipped up into a delicious topping.
Reddi Whip is perfect for topping sundaes, pies, cakes, donuts, cupcakes, and pretty much anything you want to add deliciousness to!
Does Cool Whip or Reddi Whip Work Better in A Recipe that Calls for Whipped Cream?
Either works! Both will probably work fine in a recipe that calls for whipped cream.
You have to remember, though, that cool whip has some added sugar and vanilla flavoring.
If you’re serving a dessert that already has strong flavors, like chocolate or caramel, the flavor profile of cool whip might not pair well with it.
In this case, Reddi whip would be a better choice.
There is also a difference in texture: Reddi whip is made with cream and nitrous oxide and has a creamy texture similar to homemade or store-bought whipped cream.
Cool whip is made primarily of vegetable oil and water, so it has more of a flaky texture—some people describe it like the texture of shaving cream.
This means that you’ll probably get better results from using cool whip if you want to frost something (like cake) or use whipped cream as an edible decoration for something else (like strawberries).
Finally, cool whip is slightly cheaper than Reddi whip, which makes it more budget-friendly.
If you’re hosting a large event where price matters (like a party or wedding), then cool whip might be the best choice because it will help you save money on food costs without sacrificing quality.
Does Cool Whip or Reddi Whip Hold up Better when Left out In Room Temperature?
If you’re going to eat the whip as-is, then cool whip is your best bet.
Cool whip is really made for immediate eating, and maintains its shape and texture with no problem when left out (as long as it’s not left out for more than two hours).
It’s also a lot easier to spread than Reddi Whip.
However, if you’re planning to bake with the whipped cream, or use it in a recipe that’ll require you to heat it up, Reddi Whip is the way to go.
Reddi Whip is made with actual dairy products like milk and cream, so when you heat it up, it’ll hold its shape better than cool whip will.