Skip to Content

The 5 Best Onions for Pickling

Pickling is a fantastic way to preserve and enhance the flavor of vegetables, and onions are no exception.

Their natural sweetness, crunch, and tangy taste make them an excellent choice for pickling.

But with so many different varieties of onions available, which ones should you choose for the perfect pickled onions?

What are the best onions for pickling? The best onions for pickling include pearl onions, cippolini onions, shallots, red onions, and sweet onions. Each of these onion varieties offers unique flavors and textures that work exceptionally well in a pickling brine, ensuring a delicious final product.

In this article, we’ll guide you through the five best onion varieties for pickling and discuss their individual attributes, so you can make the most informed choice for your next pickling project.

Let’s dive in and discover the ideal onions for creating mouthwatering pickles!

How to Pick the Right Onion

Choosing the right onion for your recipe can be a bit of a challenge considering the wide variety of options available.

However, by considering a few key factors, you can select the perfect onion to enhance the flavors and textures of your dish.

Here are five unique things to consider when picking the right onion:

  1. Flavor profile: Onions come in a range of flavors, from mild and sweet to sharp and pungent. Consider the overall taste you want to achieve in your dish. For example, sweet onions like Vidalia or Walla Walla are ideal for caramelizing, while more pungent onions like red or yellow onions work well in dishes that require a stronger flavor.
  2. Cooking method: The way you plan to cook your onions can influence your choice. Some onions hold up better to different cooking methods than others. For instance, white onions are great for frying and pickling, while red onions are perfect for grilling or eating raw in salads.
  3. Texture: Different onions have varying textures, which can impact the final result of your dish. For example, shallots and pearl onions tend to be more delicate and can easily become overcooked, while yellow onions are sturdier and can withstand longer cooking times.
  4. Color: Onions come in various colors, such as red, yellow, white, and green. Consider the visual appeal and presentation of your dish when selecting the appropriate onion. For example, red onions add a vibrant pop of color to salads and sandwiches, while white onions blend seamlessly into dishes like white sauces and light-colored soups.
  5. Seasonality and availability: Some onions, like sweet Vidalia onions, are only available during specific seasons or in certain regions. Keep in mind the availability of your preferred onion variety and consider using an alternative if it’s not in season. Additionally, local farmers’ markets are a great place to find fresh, seasonal onions that may not be available in your regular grocery store.

By taking these factors into account, you’ll be able to select the ideal onion for your culinary endeavors, ensuring a delicious and satisfying result.

The 5 Best Onions for Pickling

Pickling onions is a great way to preserve them for later use. But not all onions are created equal when it comes to pickling.

To get the best results, here are five types of onions that work best for pickling:

1. Pearl Onions

Pearl Onions

Pearl onions are a popular choice for pickling due to their small, uniform size and delightfully crisp texture.

These petite onions boast a mild, sweet flavor that complements the tangy brine used for pickling.

Pearl onions are available in white, yellow, and red varieties, offering a stunning visual display when preserved.

Their size and shape make them ideal for garnishing cocktails, adding to savory relish trays, or incorporating into various dishes.

Pickling pearl onions enhances their natural sweetness and crunchy texture, making them a delightful and versatile addition to your pantry.

2. Cippolini Onions

Cippolini Onions

Cippolini onions, known for their flattened shape and sweet, mild flavor, make a fantastic pickling option.

These Italian onions are typically smaller in size than traditional onions, with a diameter of about 1-2 inches.

Their high sugar content balances the acidity of the pickling brine, resulting in a deliciously sweet and tangy combination.

When pickled, cippolini onions can be used as a unique topping for pizzas, salads, and sandwiches, or enjoyed straight from the jar.

The delightful combination of flavor and texture that cippolini onions bring to pickling enhances any culinary creation.

3. Shallots


Shallots are another excellent candidate for pickling, offering a delicate balance of mild onion flavor and subtle sweetness.

Their small, elongated shape and papery skins make them easy to work with and convenient for pickling purposes.

Shallots bring a gourmet touch to any dish, and their natural sweetness is enhanced through the pickling process.

Enjoy pickled shallots as a topping for burgers, mixed into grain salads, or incorporated into elegant appetizers.

No matter how you use them, pickled shallots provide a touch of sophistication to your culinary creations.

4. Red Onions

Red Onions

Red onions, with their vibrant color and punchy flavor, are a fantastic pickling option.

They provide a robust, tangy bite that works well with the acidity of the pickling brine.

The rich purple hue of red onions turns a beautiful shade of pink when pickled, adding a pop of color to any dish.

Pickled red onions are perfect for adding zesty flavor and crunch to tacos, sandwiches, and salads.

They also make a delicious condiment for grilled meats and roasted vegetables.

The versatility of pickled red onions is hard to beat, making them a favorite for home cooks everywhere.

5. Sweet Onions

Sweet Onions

Sweet onions, such as Vidalia, Walla Walla, or Maui, provide a mellow, sugary flavor that’s ideal for pickling.

Their larger size and thick, juicy layers make them a satisfying addition to a variety of meals.

When paired with a bright, tangy pickling brine, sweet onions develop a refined taste that enhances their natural sweetness.

Pickled sweet onions make a delicious condiment for everything from sausages and hot dogs to grilled fish and roasted vegetables.

Their tender, toothsome texture and pleasant mildness make pickled sweet onions a versatile and appealing choice for any dish.

Website | + posts

Jenny has always been passionate about cooking, and she uses her platform to share her joy of food with others. Her recipes are easy to follow, and she loves giving tips and tricks to help others create their own unique culinary creations.