Skip to Content

What Does Schlotzsky’s Signature Sauce Taste Like?

Schlotzsky’s is a popular sandwich chain that has been serving up their signature sandwiches for over 50 years.

One of the key ingredients that sets Schlotzsky’s apart from other sandwich shops is their signature sauce.

This hot sauce adds a tangy and spicy kick to their sandwiches, and it is made with a blend of mustard, garlic dressing, and other secret ingredients that give it a unique flavor.

The original sandwich at Schlotzsky’s comes with cotto salami, mozzarella, sliced onion, and sourdough bread.

The signature sauce pairs perfectly with these toppings, adding an extra layer of flavor to the already delicious sandwich. But the sauce isn’t just limited to sandwiches – some people even use it in their own recipes.

If you’re looking for ways to incorporate Schlotzsky’s signature sauce into your cooking, there are plenty of options.

You can use it as a dip for potato chips or veggies, or as a spread on a sandwich bun. You could even try using it as a marinade for chicken or steak.

But what does Schlotzsky’s signature sauce actually taste like?

Well, that’s hard to describe in words. It has a tangy and slightly sweet flavor from the mustard and garlic dressing, but also packs quite a bit of heat. It’s not overwhelmingly spicy though – just enough to give your taste buds a little kick.

What is Schlotzsky’s Signature Sauce?

Schlotzsky’s is a popular fast-casual restaurant chain that has been serving up delicious sandwiches for over 50 years. While there are many reasons why people love Schlotzsky’s, one of the most important factors is their signature sauce. This sauce is so good that customers often ask what it tastes like and how it’s made. In this section, we’ll take a closer look at the secret recipe of Schlotzsky’s signature sauce.

A Unique Blend of Over 20 Ingredients

Schlotzsky’s signature sauce is a unique blend of more than 20 ingredients. The exact recipe for the sauce is a closely guarded secret that only a select few at Schlotzsky’s know. However, we do know some of the key ingredients that go into making this delicious sauce.

One of the main ingredients in Schlotzsky’s signature sauce is red wine vinegar. This gives the sauce its tangy flavor and helps to balance out some of the sweeter ingredients. Other key ingredients include sugar, garlic powder, onion powder, paprika, and mustard seed.

To make the sauce, all of these ingredients are mixed together in just the right proportions to create a perfectly balanced flavor profile. The result is a smooth and creamy sauce with just the right amount of sweetness and tanginess.

Made Fresh Daily for Maximum Flavor

Another reason why Schlotzsky’s signature sauce is so delicious is because it’s made fresh daily. Unlike other fast-food chains that use pre-packaged sauces or dressings, Schlotzsky’s makes their signature sauce in-house every day.

This ensures that the sauce is always fresh and flavorful. It also means that each batch can be adjusted slightly to account for any variations in ingredient quality or freshness.

Key Component in Many Popular Sandwiches

Schlotzsky’s signature sauce isn’t just delicious on its own – it’s also a key component in many of the restaurant’s most popular sandwiches. The Original sandwich, for example, features ham, salami, cheddar cheese, and Schlotzsky’s signature sauce.

Other sandwiches that feature the sauce include the Turkey Bacon Club and the Angus Roast Beef & Cheese. In each case, the sauce adds an extra layer of flavor that takes these sandwiches to the next level.

What Does Schlotzsky’s Signature Sauce Taste Like?

Schlotzsky’s signature sauce is a creamy and tangy blend that takes any dish to the next level.

The sauce is made up of mayonnaise, mustard, and spices that create a unique flavor profile. The creaminess of the mayo is balanced out by the tanginess of the mustard, creating a perfect harmony of flavors. The spices add an extra layer of complexity to the sauce, making it more than just your average condiment.

Slightly Sweet with a Hint of Smokiness

One of the most notable aspects of Schlotzsky’s signature sauce is its slightly sweet taste with a hint of smokiness. This sweetness comes from the combination of ingredients used in the sauce, including sugar and vinegar. The smokiness can be attributed to some type of smoked spice or ingredient used in the recipe. Together, these flavors make for a unique taste that sets Schlotzsky’s apart from other sandwich shops.

Versatile Condiment

Schlotzsky’s signature sauce isn’t just for sandwiches – it’s also an incredibly versatile condiment! It pairs well with fries as a dipping sauce or can be used as a spread on burgers and hot dogs. Its creamy texture makes it perfect for spreading on bread or using as a dip. Because it has such a unique flavor profile, it can be used to add an extra kick to any dish.

Pairing Suggestions for Schlotzsky’s Signature Sauce

Schlotzsky’s Signature Sauce is known for its bold and spicy flavor. It pairs exceptionally well with dishes that have jalapeno cheese as an ingredient. The heat from the jalapenos in the cheese complements the spiciness of the sauce, creating a perfect balance of flavors.

One excellent dish to pair with Schlotzsky’s Signature Sauce is jalapeno poppers. These delicious appetizers are made by stuffing jalapenos with cream cheese and cheddar cheese, then deep-frying them until golden brown. The creamy filling and crispy exterior of the poppers are a perfect match for the tangy and spicy sauce.

Another great option is nachos topped with jalapeno cheese sauce. The combination of crunchy tortilla chips, melted cheese, and zesty sauce creates a mouth-watering explosion of flavors that will leave you wanting more.

Cheddar Cheese-based Dishes

In addition to jalapeno cheese-based dishes, Schlotzsky’s Signature Sauce also pairs well with cheddar cheese-based dishes. Cheddar has a sharp and tangy flavor that complements the boldness of the sauce.

One classic dish that goes perfectly with Schlotzsky’s Signature Sauce is macaroni and cheese. The creamy texture of the pasta combined with gooey melted cheddar makes for an indulgent meal that can be taken up a notch by adding some signature sauce on top.

Another excellent pairing suggestion is grilled cheese sandwiches. The buttery bread and melted cheddar create a comforting base for the spicy sauce to add some extra kick to your sandwich.

Parmesan Cheese

Parmesan is another type of cheese that can enhance the taste of Schlotzsky’s Signature Sauce when sprinkled on top of any dish paired with it. Parmesan has a nutty flavor profile which adds depth to the sauce and complements its tanginess.

One delicious way to use Parmesan cheese with Schlotzsky’s Signature Sauce is by sprinkling it over a Caesar salad. The combination of the tangy dressing, crispy lettuce, and salty Parmesan creates a perfect balance of flavors that pairs well with the spicy sauce.

Baking Soda

Adding baking soda to Schlotzsky’s Signature Sauce can help balance out its acidity and make it more versatile for pairing with different types of food. A teaspoon of baking soda added to the sauce will neutralize some of the acid in it, making it less overpowering.

One great dish that can benefit from this trick is buffalo chicken wings. The tangy and spicy sauce typically used on these wings can be overwhelming, but adding some baking soda to Schlotzsky’s Signature Sauce before coating your wings will make them more palatable without sacrificing any flavor.


In conclusion, Schlotzsky’s Signature Sauce is a delicious addition to any meal. With its unique blend of ingredients, it adds just the right amount of heat and flavor to any dish. Whether you’re using it as a starter for your guests or as a topping for your favorite sandwich, this sauce is sure to impress.

One thing to keep in mind when using Schlotzsky’s Signature Sauce is that a little goes a long way. Just one ounce of this sauce can pack quite a punch! If you’re looking for something with less heat, consider mixing it with some water or light mayo.

There are plenty of options to choose from. Try using Schlotzsky’s Signature Sauce as a topping for your burger or hot dog, or use it as a dip for your fries or onion rings. It also pairs well with lettuce and tomato on top of your bun!

Website | + posts

Jenny has always been passionate about cooking, and she uses her platform to share her joy of food with others. Her recipes are easy to follow, and she loves giving tips and tricks to help others create their own unique culinary creations.