The Costco Item Shoppers Say Isn’t Worth the Hype Anymore
Costco’s rotisserie chicken, once a beloved staple of the warehouse giant, is losing its shine among shoppers. While it remains one of the most affordable options in the store at just $4.99, many customers now argue that it no longer lives up to its legendary reputation. Complaints about flavor, texture, and even ethical concerns have left some loyal fans questioning whether this iconic item is still worth buying.

What’s Changed?
For years, Costco’s rotisserie chicken was celebrated for its juicy meat, crispy skin, and unbeatable price. However, recent feedback suggests a decline in quality. Customers have described the chicken as tasting “chemically” or “soapy,” with some attributing these issues to changes in packaging or preparation methods. Others have noted that the meat seems drier and less flavorful than it used to be.

Adding to the dissatisfaction are ethical concerns. Costco has faced criticism for its chicken farming practices, with reports of poor animal welfare conditions surfacing in recent years. These revelations have led some shoppers to reconsider their purchase altogether, opting for alternatives from competitors like Publix or local grocery stores that offer better-tasting and ethically sourced options.
Why It’s No Longer Worth the Hype
- Flavor Issues: Many customers report that the chicken doesn’t taste as fresh or savory as it once did.
- Texture Problems: The meat is often described as dry and lacking the tenderness customers expect.
- Ethical Concerns: Allegations of poor farming practices have tarnished the product’s reputation.
- Stiff Competition: Other retailers are offering juicier, better-seasoned rotisserie chickens, albeit at a slightly higher price.
The Bigger Picture
Costco’s rotisserie chicken isn’t just a meal—it’s a symbol of value for many shoppers. Its low price has long been a point of pride for the retailer, even as inflation impacts other products. But as quality concerns grow louder, some members are wondering if Costco is sacrificing taste and ethics to keep costs low.
While it remains a convenient and budget-friendly option for feeding families, Costco’s rotisserie chicken may no longer be the unbeatable deal it once was. For those seeking better flavor or more humane sourcing practices, it might be time to look elsewhere—or at least think twice before tossing one into their cart.