Skip to Content

Butterfinger Cake Recipe

Some folks love watching a video for recipes.

So, we’ve put together some videos here for you to check out.

But if you’re excited about making the best Butterfinger Poke Cake, keep reading!

This Butterfinger Cake Recipe is special.

People love the mix of tastes and feels.

The moist yellow cake teams up with the sweet caramel and sweetened condensed milk.

A layer of crushed Butterfingers adds a nice crunch.

And, the Cool Whip makes it super creamy. It’s simple to make and everyone loves it.

This cake is perfect for get-togethers.

It’s quick to make so it’s great for busy people.

It’s loved by fans of caramel and chocolate.

Perfect for potlucks or dinner parties.

Everyone will be drawn to this irresistible treat.

Find out why it’s a hit for decadent cakes and potluck desserts.

Exact Ingredients You’ll Need

For this tasty Butterfinger Cake, you need the right Butterfinger Cake Ingredients. Begin with a Boxed Cake Mix. Yellow or chocolate cake mixes are great. They need eggs, oil, and water added, as the package says.

Then, add a jar of Caramel Topping to the mix for a sweet kick. Also, you’ll use sweetened condensed milk. These make the cake tasty. For the top, use a tub of Whipped Topping such as Cool Whip.

For a fun crunch, crush four Butterfinger bars. Mixing the creamy topping with the bars is delicious. Both new and expert bakers will love making this yummy cake with these ingredients.

Step-by-Step Instructions

Creating the Easy Butterfinger Poke Cake is easy with this simple guide. Let’s walk through the steps together.

  1. Preheat Your Oven: First, preheat your oven following the cake mix directions.
  2. Bake the Cake: Make the cake as the box says in a 9×13-inch pan. This makes it moist and yummy.
  3. Poke the Cake: While warm, poke holes in the cake. This helps the toppings soak in for more flavor.
  4. Add the Toppings: Mix caramel topping and milk. Pour over the cake to fill the holes.
  1. Cool the Cake: Let the cake cool. It’s an important step for the next parts.
  2. Spread Cool Whip: After cooling, spread Cool Whip on the cake.
  3. Add Crushed Butterfingers: Finally, add crushed Butterfingers. They give the cake a great crunch.

Just follow these baking method and dessert preparation steps. Then, you’ll have a yummy Easy Butterfinger Poke Cake to share. Enjoy!

Tips & Tricks

To make your Butterfinger Cake better, use these pro baking tips. Start by freezing the Butterfingers before candy bar crushing. This makes everything neater and easier. When putting holes in your cake, a fork or straw works great. This cake poking technique spreads the caramel well, making every bite sweet.

After the cake cools, add Cool Whip and candy pieces. Add them only when the cake is cool. This step makes your treat look good and taste right. Want to change it up? Use different candies instead of Butterfingers. Snickers or M&Ms can make your cake special to you, an enhanced cake recipe just for you.

Serving Suggestions

When you think about presenting a cake, small details matter a lot. Add some chocolate syrup on the top before you serve it. This makes it look better and taste even more delicious.

If you want a special way to show your desserts, think about putting fruit on the side. Raspberries help balance the cake’s sweetness with their tartness. They also make it look pretty with their bright color. Or, maybe vanilla ice cream is more your style for a classic combo.

The little extras can really change how dessert looks and tastes. Put fresh mint leaves next to each slice. They’re not just for looks. They also make every bite feel cool and fresh. Arranging them neatly makes your dessert look like something from a fancy restaurant.

Looking for a good drink to go with your cake? This cake goes well with a lot of drinks. Milk, coffee, or maybe a sweet wine after dinner. Try these pairing ideas to make your cake and drink stand out.

How to Store

Storing Butterfinger Cake the right way is very important. Keep it in the fridge, covered. This will help it stay moist and fresh for about a week. It will keep the cake’s crispy and creamy mix just right. Use a sealed container or tightly wrap in plastic to dodge fridge smells.

Want to keep it longer? You can freeze the cake for three months. Do this with slices or the whole cake. Wrap it in foil or place in a freezer-safe box to avoid freezer burn. Let the cake thaw in the fridge overnight before enjoying it again. Thawing slowly keeps the cake just as tasty.

Using these storage tips, you can make your Butterfinger Cake early. Or keep leftover cake fresh. These tricks help your cake taste great, even after a few days. Happy baking and enjoying your delicious desserts!

jenny happy muncher
 | Website

Jenny has always been passionate about cooking, and she uses her platform to share her joy of food with others. Her recipes are easy to follow, and she loves giving tips and tricks to help others create their own unique culinary creations.