Skip to Content

Amish Potato Salad (Old-Fashioned Recipe)

Some folks like video more than reading.

So, we found some helpful videos for you.

They’re right here in this post.

This Amish potato salad is a timeless favorite.

It’s known for its creamy, tangy taste.

It’s perfect for picnics, potlucks, and holidays.

The magic is in the dressing.

It mixes real mayo, mustard, vinegar, sugar, and salt.

This covers the potatoes and eggs, giving a great mix of flavors and textures.

Many choose homemade over store-bought.

This potato salad is simple and balanced. It’s sweet and tangy, perfect for any summer party or event.

Once you taste it, you’ll see why it’s so loved. It’s a key part of Amish cooking tradition.

Exact Ingredients You’ll Need

For the perfect Amish potato salad, you need some special ingredients. Choose Yukon Gold potatoes for their rich taste. Other types of potatoes work well too.

  • 1 ½ cups of real mayonnaise
  • 3 tablespoons of mustard
  • 2 tablespoons of white vinegar
  • 1/4 cup of granulated sugar
  • ½ teaspoon of salt
  • 6 chopped boiled eggs
  • ½ cup of diced celery
  • ½ cup of finely diced onion

Each ingredient is crucial in making this salad taste amazing. The dressing mixes real mayonnaise, mustard, and white vinegar. Granulated sugar adds a sweet touch, while salt balances everything.

Boiled eggs and celery are key for texture and taste. They make every bite of this salad delicious.

Step-by-Step Instructions

Learning how to make Amish potato salad is fun and improves your cooking skills. Start by peeling and cutting your potatoes into small pieces. Then, add them to boiling water.

Let them cook until soft. It usually takes 10-15 minutes. Test them by poking with a fork. When ready, drain and let them cool.

As the potatoes cool, mix the dressing. In a bowl, mix real mayonnaise, mustard, white vinegar, sugar, and salt. Mix until smooth, making a tangy dressing for your salad.

Now, add the cooled potatoes to the dressing gently. Make sure all potatoes get covered with the flavorful dressing. Add hard-boiled eggs, celery, and onion next. Mix everything well.

Now, put the salad in a serving dish. For better taste, keep it in the fridge. Let it chill well before serving. This step helps the flavors mix perfectly.

This how to make Amish potato salad guide leads to a tasty dish. It mixes creamy and crispy tastes. It’s great for meals with loved ones or any day.

Tips & Tricks

Elevate your Amish potato salad with these best potato salad tips to enhance flavor and achieve the perfect texture.

First, salt the water before boiling the potatoes. This step makes the potatoes tastier. After boiling, be sure to really cool them off. Mixing hot potatoes with the dressing makes it all oily. You want your salad to be creamy, right?

Want more flavor? Try adding some black pepper or paprika. For a tangy taste, use apple cider vinegar or sweet pickle relish.

This recipe can change a lot. You can add things like red onions, pickles, or bacon bits. It makes the salad even more delicious.

Some more tips for the best potato salad:

  • Use waxy potatoes like Yukon Gold for a creamy texture.
  • Make sure to chill the salad for at least an hour before serving to let the flavors meld together.

By using these best potato salad tips, you can make a dish just how you like it.

Serving Suggestions

This tasty Amish potato salad is great with many meals. It’s perfect with grilled dishes at barbecues and parties. You can eat it with burgers, hot dogs, ribs, or chicken. Its soft taste goes really well with these.

To make a perfect picnic meal, add this salad with coleslaw, macaroni salad, beans, and corn. This mix will fill up and please everyone.

This salad stands out at picnics. It’s smooth and helps make summer meals great. It’s a favorite for barbecues and parties. These ideas will help your guests have a great time with tasty food.

How to Store

Storing your Amish potato salad right keeps it fresh and tasty. First, put the salad in a sealed container. Then, refrigerate it at 40°F or lower. This stops bacteria from growing, keeping your food safe. Don’t keep the potato salad out for over 2 hours, or it might not be safe to eat.

Eat the salad within 3-4 days for the best flavor and safety. To keep it cool at picnics, use a cooler with ice packs. This keeps the salad fresh and safe to enjoy with friends and family outdoors.

By following these steps, your potato salad will last longer. Storing it right and keeping it cold lets you enjoy every delicious bite without worry.

jenny happy muncher
 | Website

Jenny has always been passionate about cooking, and she uses her platform to share her joy of food with others. Her recipes are easy to follow, and she loves giving tips and tricks to help others create their own unique culinary creations.