9 Popular Butter Brands Ranked By Real Butter Content

Butter, oh glorious butter! That golden spread that makes everything taste better. But not all butters are created equal.

Some boast a richer, creamier texture and deeper flavor than others, all thanks to the magic of butterfat.

This article dives deep into the world of butter, ranking nine popular brands based on their real butter content – get ready to discover your new favorite!

We’ve crunched the numbers (and tasted the results!) to bring you the ultimate butter showdown.

Prepare for a delicious journey through the world of dairy delight, where percentage points matter and creamy goodness reigns supreme.

Danish Creamery Butter

Topping our list with an impressive 85% butterfat, Danish Creamery butter is the gold standard for richness and flavor. Its luxurious texture is perfect for spreading, baking, and everything in between. This butter truly embodies the European style, delivering a depth of flavor that’s hard to beat.

Nellie’s Butter

Coming in a close second, Nellie’s butter boasts a remarkable 84% butterfat. This butter offers a similarly luxurious experience to Danish Creamery, proving that high butterfat content truly translates to superior taste and texture.

Kerrygold Pure Irish Butter

With 82% butterfat, Kerrygold needs no introduction. This iconic Irish butter has won hearts (and taste buds) worldwide for its rich, creamy taste and distinctive grass-fed flavor. A true classic.

Nature’s Promise Organic Butter

Another contender in the 82% butterfat club, Nature’s Promise Organic delivers a delicious and creamy experience with the added bonus of organic certification. Perfect for those seeking a healthier, yet equally delicious, option.

Tillamook Sea Salted Butter

Tillamook’s sea salted butter brings a delightful briny twist to the party, with 81% butterfat delivering a creamy base for the subtle saltiness. A fantastic choice for both sweet and savory applications.

Cabot Salted Butter

At 80.6% butterfat, Cabot Salted Butter is a strong contender, offering a classic salted butter experience with a good balance of flavor and texture. A solid choice for everyday use.

Land O’Lakes Butter

A household name, Land O’Lakes butter holds its own with 80% butterfat. While perhaps not as intensely flavorful as some others on the list, it remains a reliable and widely available option.

Challenge Butter

Challenge Butter focuses on authenticity, using minimal ingredients to deliver a pure butter experience. While the exact butterfat percentage isn’t specified, its quality speaks for itself. A good everyday butter choice.

Horizon Organic Butter

Rounding out our list is Horizon Organic butter. While the exact butterfat percentage isn’t explicitly stated, its organic certification and commitment to quality make it a worthy addition to this list. A good option for health-conscious consumers.